The
Dynamics
All these cars share some common characteristics in their
handling and road holding abilities. A car's handling ability is most easily judged when
cornering at high speeds. There are mainly three types of cornering behavior:
Understeer (which denotes a car's tendency to exit the
curve by following a trajectory whose radius is longer than the corner's)
Oversteer (which is characterized by the tendency of a
car to follow a radius that is shorter than the corner's)
Neutral (a behavior in which a car follows naturally a
curve's radius)
Ideally all cars should of course display neutral cornering
characteristics. Then again we are not living in an ideal world.
Each type of car has a natural tendency for one of the
above mentioned road holding characteristics depending on its architecture (mass
distribution, engine position, driven wheels, inertia,...). Below you will find the major
characteristics which best describe each type of car's behavior on dry tarmac surfaces.
Front wheel drive cars
Most front wheel drive cars display a heavy understeering
behavior while cornering (at road holding limit speeds). This is due to the fact that in
front wheel drive cars most of the car's weight is distributed in the front part of the
car. This induces great inertia forces while in a corner. Since no opposite force is
present to spin the car around its vertical axis (i.e. no rear wheel traction) the car
understeers. These cars have to be driven hard in order to obtain fast cornering. You have
to "break late" and I mean really late. Braking late
"charges" the front wheels making them "stick" to the road and
therefore adds traction while, at the same time, discharges the rear axle making the rear
wheels more subject to sliding. When the brake pedal is released the rear axle is charged
again helping the car out of the corner. The usual way to drive fast this kind of car is
what is known as left foot braking. This technique consists in using your
left foot to brake while using the right foot to accelerate at the same time. Left foot
braking is a demanding technique and takes a long time to master. It can, therefore, be
dangerous to novices. The usual effect of braking with the left foot is to lock the rear
wheels of the car thus inducing an oversteering character to the handling.
 |
Understeering
As you might have guessed these are not the most
"fun" cars to drive. Their market predominance is mainly due to the fact that
they feel "reassuring " to inexperienced everyday drivers. I mean by that that
if a front wheel drive car enters a corner too fast, by driver misjudgment or
inexperience, the usual driver's reaction is to brake while inside the corner and
subsequently lift his right foot from the gas pedal. A front wheel drive car in this
situation will reduce its understeering character and enroll the corner more easily thus
"forgiving" its driver's optimism. A second reason for the front wheel driven
car's predominance is their reduced cost of manufacturing compared to other types of
cars..
Rear wheel drive cars
This type of car used to dominate the market until the
early 80s. They still prevail in the US but they do so for reasons that have nothing to do
with sporty driving.
Evidently in these cars the rear wheels are driven by the
engine. This allows for a better mass distribution inducing less inertia [Some of these
cars such as the Porsche 924, 944, 968 and the Alfa Romeo GTV and GTV6 had the gear box
mounted on the rear axle to further improve mass distribution]. Rear wheel drive cars have
a natural tendency to oversteer. When one of these cars enters a corner fast (with the gas
pedal down) its rear wheels will lose traction (will have a tendency to spin) and the
gyroscopic force they produce will lead them off the curve. This road holding
characteristic, although spectacular, is very far from efficient. BMWs
and Mercedes-Benz cars are still made this way, mainly for tradition's sake.
Oversteering
You may note that these cars are much more fun to drive
than front wheel drive cars are. Their oversteering can be easily modulated by
"dosing" the gas pedal. Rear wheel drive vehicles tend to "surprise"
inexperienced drivers, especially the most powerful ones.
An extreme example of rear wheel drive car is the Porsche
911 series. In these cars not only the traction is applied to the rear wheels but the
engine is also mounted at the rear of the car in an overhang position (behind the rear
wheels axle). The Porsche 911 series has been known as very difficult to drive at the
limit since, when cornered, the inertia induced by the overhanging engine will easily have
the car spinning around its vertical axis.
The progressive elimination of this breed of car is due to
the higher manufacturing costs they induce. Additionnaly the oversteering they induce is
sometimes excessive and can lead to a total loss of control of the vehicle.
All wheel drive cars
The road holding characteristics of these cars are a bit
more complex. They are a combination of both of the above and very far from neutral.
Usually 4 wheel drive cars are based in front or rear wheel drive versions of the same
models. This fact greatly influences their handling (i.e. cars that are based on rear
wheel drive models display a more oversteering type of handling whereas cars that are
based on front wheel drive models display an understeering type of handling). This is just
a rule of thumb however and, depending on engine power, one or the other type of handling
may prevail.
Usually, this type of vehicle changes its handling
characteristics while in a corner. The car has a tendency to understeer when entering the
corner and oversteer when exiting. One can modulate this characteristic by using the
throttle and brake pedals in a way to induce a neutral type of handling. Like in front
wheel drive cars the driver has to "brake late" when entering
the corner and push the gas pedal while inside the corner in order to allow a "torque
transfer" (operated by self
locking differentials) to the rear wheels. The torque transfer is most noticable in
turbocharged vehicles. When the turbocharger reaches its full throttle speed, at around
100,000-150,000 RPM depending on the model, and the car's engine develops its maximum
torque. When this happens the front wheel will have a tendency to spin. Their spin
detected by the center differential which will progressively lock and send engine torque
to the rear wheels thus inducing oversteer.
Although these cars are not such "fun" to drive
as are rear wheel drive cars they are so much faster and efficient that unless one drives
them he is unable to imagine the cornering speeds 4wd cars are able to reach.
The major drawbacks of 4wd turbocharged cars when compared
with their 2wd counterparts are:
Increased mechanical complexity affecting their price and
weight
Higher mechanical losses due to the number of gears to drive
(differentials, axles, ...)
The famous "turbo lag" effect (on turbocharged versions) which
forces the driver to anticipate the car's reactions
The "nervous" reactions the cars might have when changing
their handling characteristic from understeer to oversteer
As you might have guessed these cars are a lot more demanding when driven
to the limit. A certain time is necessary for a novice before he can master and anticipate
the car's reactions. Most examples of full time 4WD turbocharged cars where developped in
the sole purpose of competing in the World Rally Championship.
One can only regret the progressive disappearance of four wheel drive
turbocharged cars from the vendors' catalogues. The days when a car enthusiast could opt
for this breed are unfortunately (almost) over.
Please remember to drive safely... |